Start With the Governing Rating Method
No single hearing-impairment formula applies to every occupational claim. The calculation depends on the claim system, the rating method it adopts, and the testing requirements that govern the evaluation.
This article explains a hearing-loss method described in a source discussing the AMA Guides Sixth Edition. That method uses pure-tone thresholds at 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz, but it should not be treated as universal. The AMA’s overview of permanent impairment ratings advises checking the applicable edition and jurisdictional rules.
For adjusters, attorneys, and injured workers, a percentage is meaningful only when its basis is clear: which frequencies were tested, how the results were calculated, and which authority governs the rating. A separate proposed otolaryngology guideline, for example, uses a different frequency-weighting method and is not the AMA Guides formula (guideline details).
Our physicians identify the governing framework and document the audiometric findings before interpreting a rating. For federal claims, NorCal Medical Consulting also aligns documentation with applicable OWCP standards, helping reviewers trace the method from test results to conclusions.
How Occupational Hearing Loss Is Calculated
Occupational hearing impairment is calculated under the rating method required by the applicable compensation system. There is no universal formula: the governing rules determine which thresholds, frequencies, and conversion method apply. For federal claims, identify the required schedule and testing requirements before calculating. Our team at NorCal Medical Consulting conducts specialized auditory evaluations that can include Auditory Steady-State Response (ASSR) testing from 500 Hz through 4,000 Hz, including 3,000 Hz when the applicable schedule requires it.
The four-frequency calculation described in a Hearing Journal article about the AMA Guides Sixth Edition uses each ear’s thresholds at 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz. It is distinct from a six-division method in a separate proposed otolaryngologic impairment guideline, which weights the 1,000- and 2,000-Hz thresholds and uses a different frequency set for its calculation. That proposal is not the AMA Guides formula, so the methods must not be combined. The proposed guideline identifies its own approach and does not establish the rules for U.S. claims.
Under the AMA Sixth Edition method reported in the article, first average the four thresholds separately for each ear. To calculate monaural impairment, subtract 25 dB from that ear’s pure-tone average (PTA) and multiply the remainder by 1.5%. Then combine the better- and worse-ear impairment figures by weighting the better ear five times, adding the worse-ear figure, and dividing by six. Finally, use Table 11-3 to convert the binaural impairment result to whole person impairment (WPI). The Hearing Journal article reports this sequence and example.
In that example, right-ear thresholds of 45, 50, 50, and 55 dB HL produce a 50 dB HL PTA and 37.5% monaural impairment. Left-ear thresholds of 40 dB HL at all four frequencies produce a 40 dB HL PTA and 22.5% monaural impairment. The binaural result is [(5 × 22.5) + 37.5] ÷ 6 = 25%, which the example converts to 9% WPI using Table 11-3.
Treat these figures as an illustration, not a substitute for checking the precise Guides edition and claim rules. The AMA overview identifies Chapter 11 as the relevant section for ear, nose, throat, and related structures, but it does not provide this hearing formula. The AMA Guides overview also emphasizes using the applicable edition. For the claim-specific calculation context, see how occupational hearing loss is calculated.
What an AMA Impairment Rating Represents
An AMA impairment rating is a physician’s estimate of permanent loss or loss of use of a body function or structure, which the physician makes under the applicable AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. Physicians generally assess and document permanent impairment after maximum medical improvement (MMI), when the condition has stabilized and is unlikely to change substantially over the next year, with or without treatment.
The rating describes medical impairment, not disability. Impairment measures the loss in body function; disability concerns how that condition affects a person’s ability to work or carry out other activities. The distinction matters in hearing-loss claims, where a percentage does not, by itself, establish a worker’s ability to perform a particular job.
Nor does an impairment percentage alone determine benefits or the final value of a claim. The applicable jurisdiction and claim system govern the rating's application, and other rules may affect the compensation decision. The AMA’s overview of permanent impairment ratings explains that a physician’s rating is one input in a broader process, not the compensation decision itself.
For adjusters and attorneys, the report should identify the medical basis for the rating and the Guides content that supports it. The AMA describes a properly completed report that uses the appropriate Guides material as a standard for documenting permanent impairment in insurance and legal proceedings. NorCal Medical Consulting’s physicians prepare evidence-based evaluations and written reports for occupational hearing-loss claims and align findings to the governing claim framework.
An AMA rating answers a medical question about lasting loss. It does not settle entitlement, work capacity, or claim value; those questions require separate consideration under the applicable legal and compensation rules.
How AMA Rating Methods Use Medical Findings
An impairment rating under the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment applies the edition and method required for the claim to the documented medical findings. It does not use one formula for every injury or body system.
The evaluator first identifies the diagnosis, then reviews relevant examination results, objective test findings, and functional history. The applicable body-system criteria and tables determine how those findings support a rating. Depending on the edition and method, the calculation may use diagnosis-based criteria, functional measures, or specified modifiers and adjustments.
That sequence is a framework, not a substitute for the technical instructions in the required edition. The AMA’s overview of permanent impairment evaluation identifies Chapter 11 as covering the ear, nose, throat, and related structures, but does not provide a hearing-loss formula or worked calculation.
For hearing claims, do not assume that a general audiology guideline supplies the AMA method. One published proposed guideline for rating otolaryngologic impairment uses its own testing and calculation approach; do not treat it as an AMA Guides formula without checking the governing edition.
A reviewable report names the edition and method, identifies the findings used, and explains how those findings meet the selected criteria. Our physicians conduct auditory evaluations using objective testing, including ASSR across 500 Hz to 4,000 Hz, with 3,000 Hz included for the Department of Labor schedule where required. The report should make clear which findings support the rating and which rules govern the claim.
For workers’ compensation matters, the applicable jurisdiction or federal program determines the required edition and rating rules. NorCal Medical Consulting prepares evaluations for federal claims, including Longshore and Defense Base Act matters, with documentation aligned to OWCP requirements.
Verify the Edition Required for the Claim
The edition of the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment that applies depends on the governing law and claim type, not simply on which edition is newest. State statutes, regulations, and claim-specific instructions may prescribe a particular edition or update.
The American Medical Association identifies the Sixth Edition as its current edition and reports updates to Chapter 11, which covers the ear, nose, throat, and related structures. Its overview notes a Chapter 11 update in 2025, but that publication update does not mean every claim must use the newest material. Check the applicable jurisdiction’s adoption rules and the requirements for the specific evaluation before rating.
Federal claims may follow distinct schedules or instructions. For federal hearing-loss matters, confirm the controlling Department of Labor schedule for the claim, including its required frequency inputs. The Sixth Edition schedule identified for these matters includes 3,000 Hz, but that requirement should not be assumed to govern every state or federal case. NorCal Medical Consulting conducts specialized auditory evaluations using ASSR testing from 500 Hz through 4,000 Hz, including 3,000 Hz.
In the report, identify the edition, applicable update, and jurisdictional basis for selecting them. The AMA cautions that outdated Guides can produce inequitable ratings as medical science and knowledge of long-term outcomes change. This record lets reviewers assess whether the rating method fits the claim rather than relying on an unexplained reference to an edition.
Keep the medical impairment rating separate from later legal or non-medical adjustments. The AMA recommends completing the standard rating under the appropriate Guides content first, then applying jurisdiction-specific adjustments required by regulators. Our physicians document the medical findings and rating method so those later decisions can be distinguished from the impairment assessment.
Clarify What the 1 3 6 Rule Means
Available sources do not establish the “1/3/6 rule” as one universally accepted hearing-loss rating formula. Its meaning depends on the guideline or compensation system using the term, so the number sequence alone does not identify the required frequencies, thresholds, or arithmetic.
Do not apply a formula based on shorthand without first identifying its source and the governing protocol. The Hearing Journal’s description of the AMA Guides method uses thresholds at 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz. The U.S. Department of Labor Sixth Edition schedule referenced for federal claims also calls for thresholds at 500, 1,000, 2,000, and 3,000 Hz. These frequency sets do not establish a general “1/3/6 rule.” Do not treat a separate guideline’s formula as interchangeable with the applicable AMA Guides method.
OSHA’s occupational noise standard, 29 C.F.R. § 1910.95, addresses workplace noise exposure and audiometric monitoring; it is not itself a workers’ compensation impairment-rating formula. For federal auditory claims, NorCal Medical Consulting evaluates hearing with ASSR testing across 500 Hz to 4,000 Hz, including 3,000 Hz, as required by the Department of Labor schedule. Our team’s reports should identify the governing schedule, test protocol, and calculation rather than rely on shorthand. For related context, see [how expert witnesses address practical listening guidelines and the 1/3/6 rule](./when-to-involve-an-expert-witness-in-hearing-loss-compensation-cases#practical-listening-guidelines-6060-rule-and-1-3-6-rule).
Separate Medical Impairment From Compensation
An impairment rating measures permanent functional loss under the method required for the claim. It is not a payout figure: compensation depends on the governing statute or program rules and the facts of the case.
The AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment provide a framework for documenting medical impairment, while government rules determine compensation. The AMA’s overview of impairment ratings makes this distinction explicit: a physician’s rating is an input to a broader decision, not the benefit calculation itself.
A benefit calculation may depend on the claim type, the body part covered, wage or earning-capacity measures, and any statutory benefit limits. The same impairment percentage can therefore lead to different results under different programs or claim circumstances.
This distinction also matters in claims under the Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act and the Defense Base Act. You must consider the rating within the applicable federal framework and claim facts; no single impairment percentage guarantees a uniform payment.
A medical report supports the claim determination by documenting findings and the reasoning behind the impairment assessment. The responsible administrator or adjudicator applies the governing rules and determines benefits. [Our team's article on how impairment assessments relate to claim outcomes](./the-impact-of-accurate-injury-assessments-on-claim-outcomes#from-assessment-to-award-how-objective-tools-quantify-impairment) explains why keeping those medical and compensation questions distinct helps make the record clearer.
Interpret Pure Tone Results in Context
A pure-tone threshold is the quietest tone a person detects at a particular frequency, reported in dB HL. Review the audiogram ear by ear and frequency by frequency rather than relying on a single summary value. Our team considers these findings alongside the claim’s governing rating method, not as a standalone legal conclusion.
Clinical references commonly describe thresholds from 0 to 20 dB HL as within the normal range, while some use 25 dB HL as the upper limit. These are general clinical reference points, not universal cutoffs for a compensation rating. The available source material does not establish either range as a legal standard, so the evaluating physician should identify the reference used and explain its relevance.
A result within a commonly used normal range does not rule out difficulty understanding speech or other hearing concerns that pure-tone testing does not measure. Interpret audiogram findings with the history, examination, and other relevant test results. See our discussion of reading audiogram findings for more on reviewing thresholds in context.
A proposed otolaryngologic impairment guideline lists physical examination, pure-tone audiometry, speech audiometry, and impedance audiometry as required tests. It also identifies auditory brainstem response, Bekesy audiometry, otoacoustic emissions, and imaging as supplementary tests, and recommends repeating pure-tone testing about three times at intervals of three to seven days (proposed otolaryngologic guideline). That proposal is not the AMA Guides method; do not substitute it for the claim’s required criteria without verification. The AMA Guides overview likewise identifies Chapter 11 as the relevant area for ear and hearing impairment, but does not supply a general clinical normal-hearing cutoff.
Make the Method Traceable
Before signing a hearing-loss rating, identify the claim system and the required edition or schedule. Then make the report traceable: state the test protocol, list the frequency inputs and audiometric findings, and show how the governing method produces the rating.
A formula described in a secondary source should not be assumed to govern every AMA, state, or federal claim. The AMA Guides overview identifies Chapter 11 as the section for ear, nose, throat, and related structures, but the applicable edition and jurisdiction-specific rules still control. A separate proposed otolaryngology guideline uses its own calculation, which should not be substituted for the required method without verification.
For federal claims, including Longshore and Defense Base Act matters, our physicians document the audiometric basis and the rating method used, including ASSR testing from 500 Hz through 4,000 Hz when appropriate to the evaluation. A clear, evidence-based report distinguishes medical impairment from disability and benefit determinations, which depend on the governing compensation rules.



